14 Comments
User's avatar
Cole Noble's avatar

Brady is fantastic. I just finished working with him for my project and he is incredibly thorough, and also informative. There is a lot of stuff I learned I was doing incorrectly, particularly as it pertains to dialogue (I like using a ton of action dialogue tags, but was formatting these incorrectly). Fixing this issue ADDED—and I shit you not—50 pages to the finished copy. I think Brady will also add a new addendum to his contract after one particular plotline in my story (oops) and I cannot endorse him enough

Frank Kidd's avatar

Yeah, it helps that he’s a very talented fiction author in his own right. About one of the only people I trust taking stylistic notes from.

Troop Brenegar's avatar

Once had an editor who came highly recommended, was editor for one of the biggest names in historical fiction, "edit" my novel for what got strung out to be 9 months, then just ghosted and lost all contact. Maybe I shouldn't have been bothered because I was getting a good deal, but at the time it was a lot of money. Lesson learned: I did it myself. No regrets.

Frank Kidd's avatar

Man, some of these horror stories are the worst. That’s awful.

Troop Brenegar's avatar

Really pushed me to develop my own editing skills, both in terms of structure/character and proofing, so in the end worth it.

Alan Schmidt's avatar

The editor for my novel took 4 months (6 weeks was promised) and didn't deliver everything they was promised. The editing was also poor, and I had to spend and additional 6 months to get it up to par. Infuriating.

A good editor is something that almost has to be word of mouth. Too easy to game forums and SEO to be able to determine quality.

Frank Kidd's avatar

Damn, I’m super sorry about that. Infuriating experience. Finding a good editor has proven to be one of the most frustrating roadblocks to getting stuff out there at least for me. They are such an indispensable part of putting out good work and I’ve found the majority of freelancers just aren’t up to the job. It’s a real catch-22.

Shadow Journal Dispatch's avatar

Great article, someone once said to me that writing is the most difficult, sad thing a person can do. I concur!

KingNullpointer's avatar

Institutional rot, & intentional destruction, has driven a massive amount of skill-drain in the (ruins of the) West. Not many sorting hats left for people who fit the role, or training camps for the "merely okay" to be made "good".

The upside of LLM/NN/"AI" tools propagating is indie authors can use them, just as well as the fraudsters. Perhaps editing will also return to being a semi-professional hobby, which should at least filter out those looking for easy money. Although it won't make the human turnaround time any faster.

One recommendation I've heard from a very intelligent person is to learn sentence diagramming. It apparently wraps up every otherwise-useless grammar term into a cohesive whole. (I read enough when I was young I could replicate mostly-correct English without learning any proper grammar, which I think is probably a common affliction for American English-speakers.)

Boomer's avatar

Great article and super timely. I am in earliest round of editing my first novel and have a short list of editors-for-hire that I am going to pull from. Will certainly be adding Brady to the consideration list. Thankfully I have a journalism background so when I finally get this to a pro, the grammar won't be too disastrous. Either way, great article. Case studies are helpful to me!

Parker McCoy's avatar

It is definitely an expensive hobby/business. Hehe. I think having an editor is great but like you say, readers care about the story first and foremost. Bad editing and mistakes can be annoying but heck, sometimes they are charming and they let us know the author is human. Awesome post, Frank.

Jeanne S's avatar

Excellent choice!

VVarren VValker's avatar

Looking at being an indie author as a hobby is really the only way to look at it. Everyone wants to make money off their hobbies, however I think you have to actually be substantial for it to be a buisiness.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 3
Comment deleted
Frank Kidd's avatar

Thank you! They were definitely there but it wasn’t in bad shape overall.